Soundbar Vs Bookshelf Speakers 2023: Which One is Better?

Anthony

Many people are turning to bookshelf speakers instead of soundbars. Due to their many benefits, soundbars have supplanted traditional stereo systems.

Since soundbars have limited capability, many people think it’s better to use good bookshelf speakers for the best sound. But what is right in this statement? Let’s compare Soundbar Vs Bookshelf Speakers for music to find out which one is better.

Soundbar

A soundbar, a speaker with a long and thin shape, is placed under or next to your TV. The Soundbar usually has one driver at the bottom and several tweeters at the top.

You will also find a separate subwoofer, which is a soundbar system that amplifies your bass frequencies. It can be compared to a bookcase speaker, which you mount above or beneath your TV sound.

A single soundbar can do the same job without having to install multiple speakers in your room and run the wire to connect them.

Soundbases are also known as sound bars. The sound bars are usually rectangular and sit directly beneath the TV. The driver faces upwards while the tweeters face you. Some soundbar speakers have a wireless subwoofer that can provide a surround sound system wirelessly.

The best Soundbars can be set up quickly and are affordable. You can also adjust the volume, bass, and sometimes the treble speaker remotely. The sound bars are equipped with a digital-to-analog (DAC) converter to process the audio signal. We will be discussing DAC in more detail later.

Why Soundbars Are So Popular

Easy to install and connect
Fewer cables
Modified design
These are well-suited for small living areas.
Incredible virtual sound and a glimpse into surround sound experience
The best sound system on the market
Bluetooth connection possible

Bookshelf Speakers

Bookshelf speakers can be small, standalone speakers that don’t usually have a subwoofer. The traditional 2-way speaker system is the bookshelf speaker; the tweeter and woofer fire out from the speaker’s front, facing you.

Bookshelf speakers are usually placed on a side table or shelf facing you. You can mount them on the wall behind your TV sound or place them on a stand. A 2-way speaker system set for quality bookshelf speakers is typical.

This usually includes a tweeter as well as a woofer. The tweeter is at the top, while the woofer is at the bottom. To enhance bass response, there may be one or two passive radiators.

Why bookshelf speakers Are So Popular

It is visually pleasing
Flexible and very flexible
Many speakers include amplifiers that enhanced stereo listening experience.
Studio-quality, accurate bass
Lightweight
Mixable and upgradeable
There are many features to choose from
Bluetooth connection possible

Soundbar Vs Bookshelf Speakers: Which Is Better?

Cost

When selecting the speaker for your theater, the cost is almost always a significant consideration.

Although we may all wish that our budgets were unlimited, it is not the case for many of us- even those with a larger budget.

Consider the cost of each speaker, such as a bookshelf or Soundbar, and the extra equipment needed to transmit bass to your home cinema.

The price of bookshelf speakers and Soundbars can be similar, depending on how good they are. But a desk speaker could be more expensive if you need an amplifier and a subwoofer to get the high-quality sound you want.

Since your two bookshelf speakers don’t have a center channel, you’ll need a center channel speaker. You might not have to pay the extra money for a speaker.

You can add more channels, but a Soundbar might be better because it has many speakers and a subwoofer that sends low-frequency music signals.

Consider how each item will be linked and what connections, transmitters, receivers, and other equipment you’ll need for your speaker system. Although inexpensive, these can add to your budget.

Sound Quality

The great sound quality of each piece of equipment is probably the most critical aspect of comparing powered stereo bookshelf speakers with Soundbars.

You should also consider the whole sound system you want. If you add stereo speakers to your system, the audio quality experience will be much more than you have.

Even though Audiophiles sometimes criticize soundbars for their excellent sound equipment, most users will be impressed with the music quality experience they can offer.

A Soundbar is a significant upgrade to the TV’s powered speakers. Soundbars can also be attractive options for home theaters.

If you compare them, you’ll probably find a better speaker set. A group of bookshelf speakers will be better than a Soundbar.

They outperform Soundbars with comparable prices because the physical components of the bookshelf speakers aid in the natural emission audio signals.

Many audiophiles choose bookshelf speakers to replace Soundbars. They can improve your home’s audio quality when added to your sound system.

But it’s important to choose the right choice for you and your budget. This is where enjoyment comes into play.

Sensitivity Rating

Speaker sensitivity (or speaker efficiency) is one of the most important aspects in speaker volume and clarity.

To be considered good, a speaker must have an efficiency rating of at least 90dBs. This efficiency rating will give you the best sound quality and the lowest power consumption.

An audio system should have a sensitivity rating (efficiency rating) of between 86 to 88dB. This is the standard, but higher-end systems should have at minimum 90dBs. Any soundbar or bookshelf speaker with a sensitivity of 84dBs or lower should be avoided.

Bookshelf speakers are specifically designed for audiophiles and will have an efficiency rating of 88 to 92dB, depending on which make or model. Soundbars are a more affordable option and have an efficiency rating of between 86 and 88 dB.

Be aware that you can still get high-efficiency soundbars of good quality, but they will cost you a lot more.

Bookshelf Speakers Vs Soundbar for Music: Input Impedance

High-quality audio is possible only if your equipment and wire can withstand impedance. A lot of people get confused about impedance. While impedance can affect speakers, it will also impact the resistance.

We won’t be discussing impedance levels with wires in this article, but we will discuss speaker impedances.

You don’t want an stereo system that has either a high or low impedance. You should look for speakers with a resistance between 4 and 8 ohms.

This bracket is ideal for bookshelf speakers, although some soundbars can have a low impedance and a high level of distortion.

While impedance doesn’t affect the music quality, it can affect how hard your equipment must work to produce that sound. To avoid potential problems with wire length or power consumption, you should always match your impedance levels.

Power Output

The power rating of any sound system is a vital feature to look at when you purchase it. This helps you understand the power required to achieve the best audio quality.

If you look at the speakers’ specifications, you will see the min and max power ratings. This is the ideal range for your power supply.

If you are looking for loud, wall-shaking sounds like rock, metal, or pop, 200W will be sufficient. 50W will suffice if you like classical, jazz, blues, or hip-hop.

The power of a bookshelf speaker can be divided into Peak / Max power and RMS power. RMS is a continuous power supply in a normal condition. This is used for matching amplifier ratings.

Peak power refers to the maximum force a speaker can produce in a short time. It is not compatible with the amplifier. RMS is often lower than Peak Power. When choosing between two speakers, it is essential to compare RMS and Peak Power.

The power output of soundbars is the total applied wattage. The power consumption is simply the wattage. The range of power consumption is generally between 20-30% and 80-90%.

Frequency Response

Frequency response is an essential characteristic of speakers that you need to be aware of. The better the frequency response, No matter what speaker you have, your speakers should have a low to high-frequency response.

A speaker’s response is a measure of how deep and bassy it can produce. Soundbars are not good if they don’t have an extra subwoofer.

Bookshelf speakers have excellent quality and inadequate response. They are usually around the 50Hz mark. They will, therefore, not require a subwoofer.

Soundbars will usually play frequencies in the middle-range and higher. The mid-range frequencies begin at around 200Hz. This means that soundbars of low quality and the mid-level price won’t reproduce the excellent sound frequencies and will not produce a great bass sound.

Drivers

There are three types of speakers: tweeters, midrange, and woofers. Sometimes, a subwoofer can be added to enhance the bass sound.

The size of sound systems is essential. Large stereo systems can play louder music and produce more bass, making the sound clearer and bolder.

Bookshelf systems typically have 5″-6.25″ and.75-1.4″ tweeters, which create a large soundstage for listening to music. The soundbars come with different sizes of tweeters, and you will most likely find a soundbar with a subwoofer.

Inputs

The primary inputs to the system are sockets and ports. Although the sound effects are minimal, better connectors necessarily improve stereo quality and reduce electronic interference.

RCA AUX cable has more flexibility than RCA, and RCA AUX combined cables are generally better. Optic audio connections are another option that allows bass quality to be transferred between devices.

To ensure great quality sound, bookshelf speakers come with a variety of connectors and cables. There are 3.5mm RCA, 3.5mm jack AUX, and dual RCA Aux cables. Customers can choose from many options to make their choice.

Looking at soundbars, you will find 3.5mm jack AUX connectors, HDML connectors, and optical wires. It is best to connect Soundbar and TV via HDMI arc.

Speaker Placement

How do you want your sound system to be placed? You can’t have your sound systems right next to you. This will cause the excellent quality to be inferior to that of the surround system. The setting of your speaker system can have a big effect on how good the sound is.

It is much easier to find the perfect combination of soundbars and bookshelf speakers for great tv speakers than position them.

Put the speakers as close to the wall as you can to get the best sound. If the speakers aren’t all the same distance from the walls, move them. The distance between the front and sidewalls should not be identical.

Your speakers should be aimed down the longest wall to allow sound waves to reach their full potential. To get the best audio, keep the speakers at ear level. You should create an ideal triangle between your speakers; the distance between your speakers and you should be equal.

Soundbars are small and lightweight and can be placed below TVs or computer monitors to deliver fantastic audio. Just make sure the Soundbar is straight under your wall-mounted LED TV.

Connectivity

Connectivity is the last technical aspect we’ll discuss. You will need to connect bookshelf speakers to your TV and audio system. Some soundbars have wireless connectivity, such as Bluetooth.

It is essential to realize that Bluetooth has a limited bandwidth, and audio will be transmitted with lossy data compression. Bluetooth will affect the sound quality to some degree.

Many soundbars come with additional audio output options, such as HDMI or optical out. Some even have the old RCA connectors.

You will experience poor sound quality if Bluetooth is used. However, some people say that the sound clarity is not important and that you won’t hear it.

Are Bookshelf Speakers Better Than a Soundbar?

It depends on your specific needs and preferences. Both bookshelf speakers and soundbars have their own advantages and disadvantages.

Bookshelf speakers are larger and more powerful than soundbars, and they often produce superior music sound. They also have more placement options and can be used as part of a bigger home theater system.

On the other hand, soundbars are smaller and easier to carry, which makes them great for smaller rooms or places where space is limited. They usually have built-in speakers and other features that make them easy to set up and use.

Read more:

FAQs

Which is better for movies, soundbars or bookshelf speakers?

Bookshelf speakers usually produce a more immersive surround sound than soundbars for movies. They can be placed around the room to expand the soundstage and enhance audio effects.

Some high-end soundbars offer surround sound and advanced sound processing.

Are bookshelf speakers better for music than soundbars?

Bookshelf speakers’ larger frequency response range and more dynamic soundstage make them better for music than soundbars.

They can provide a more realistic and precise sound, allowing you to experience all musical nuances.

Some upmarket soundbars sound like bookshelf speakers, but they have more speakers and better sound processing.

Can soundbars be used for surround sound?

Modern soundbars have many speakers and advanced sound processing for surround sound. Some soundbars incorporate wireless rear speakers or subwoofers for an immersive audio experience.

For the best surround sound experience, bookshelf speakers are still favored.

Can bookshelf speakers be used as a home theater system?

Yes, bookshelf speakers can be part of a music system for a home theater. But to listen to your devices, they usually need extra equipment like an amplifier or receiver.

For a full home setting, you may also need more speakers, like a subwoofer or a center channel.

What is the difference between a soundbar and a soundbase?

A soundbar is a long, slender speaker designed to sit beneath your TV or mounted on the wall. Conversely, a soundbase is a flat, box-shaped speaker beneath your TV.

Soundbases provide deeper and fuller bass than soundbars due to their larger drivers and internal area. However, soundbars are typically more versatile and easier to install.

Conclusion

Soundbars and bookshelf speakers have different pros and cons, so choose the one that suits your needs.

Bookshelf speakers sound better and are more flexible than soundbars, which are cheaper. You should also consider room dynamics and channel count.

If you’re looking for good audio equipment, check out https://hookeaudio.com/. Hooke Audio offers a range of products, including headphones, microphones, and recording equipment.