- Anthony
Both can’t be beaten in the never-ending battle of bookshelf speakers vs. tower speakers when it comes to sound quality. The bookshelf speakers have a clear advantage when it comes to aesthetics, meaning that they’re a better fit in most homes with a modern look. But the Tower speaker wins its sound is not as distorted at higher volumes.
So, Bookshelf Vs Tower Speakers, which is better? Keep reading this article; Hookeaudio will show you two speakers that can give you a clear answer.
Contents
Tower Speakers
Tower speakers, also known as floorstanding speakers, are placed on the floor or attached to a stand. They will typically be at least three feet tall and 7 inches wide. The depth can range from nine inches to nearly two feet.
There are many ways to describe floorstanding speakers. This represents the number of speakers that handle different audio frequencies.
Although it is difficult to say whether a 4-way speaker will be better than a 2-way, properly designed floorstanding speakers with more dedicated drivers allow the speaker designer to create more focused components on a narrower range of frequencies. This can lead to better and more precise performance.
A floorstanding speaker is the best choice for a speaker company. Music has a wide frequency response range, and size is the best way to reproduce deep bass tones. A more prominent speaker will also result in higher efficiency.
This is the measure of how much power an amplifier takes to produce a particular sound pressure level. The efficiency is measured in decibels.
A speaker delivering 88db sound pressure will need one watt of power at a meter will typically produce one watt. This number will indicate how much energy is required to drive the speaker.
More efficient floorstanding speakers will generally have more extraordinary contrasts in the music’s dynamics. Designers will be able to create more efficient speakers by using larger speaker cabinets. The floorstanding speaker gives your piece a more real-life feel.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- These are the most powerful and clearest sounding, with a very wide range of tones.
- They typically have superior dynamics than other types of floorstanding speakers.
- They can be straightforward to drive if they are efficient – but not all of them.
- If you are placed correctly in a room, you can almost feel the performers spreading out in front of you. This gives you that feeling of “being there.”
- These are great for elevating Atmos speakers.
Cons:
- They are challenging to get rid of because they are so large.
- To sound their best, most floorstanding speakers must be placed away from the back wall.
Bookshelf Speakers
Bookshelf speakers, as their name suggests, are small enough to fit on a standard bookshelf (also known as satellite speakers). However, some great ookshelf speakers can be significantly larger.
Bookshelf speakers are usually 2-way speakers with a tweeter or dedicated bass driver. Bookshelf speakers don’t usually have high efficiency.
Bookshelf speakers supplemented some of the same sonic benefits as floorstanding speakers if they are correctly set up. The Full range bookshelf speakers can be placed on shelves, but they sound best when mounted on a stand in the room.
This is very similar to floorstanding speakers. Although they won’t have the same deep bass as tower speakers, some models can produce a convincing soundstage for music combined with a subwoofer.
A good subwoofer and bookshelf speaker can give you the same sound quality as a tower speaker. You can place the speakers in various ways, making it easier for people who move frequently.
A floor-standing speaker may not take up as much space as the stand/speaker combination if there is a suitable spot for a bookshelf speaker. A bookshelf mounted on a stand can look smaller than a speaker placed in a different space.
Bookshelf speakers are a favorite of many audiophiles who enjoy small-scale music (such as a jazz quartet). They can be smaller than towers, making them appear to disappear. This gives you an excellent three-dimensional soundstage when placed on stands far from your walls.
A subwoofer can be used to reduce the bookshelf’s baseload, improving the midrange audio performance. A good subwoofer will give you the whole emotional and sensory experience of live sound if you have bookshelf speakers.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- It is small in size
- Can provide large sound stages
- It can be placed inside a cabinet or on a speaker stand.
- They can be used with an Atmos speaker stand.
Cons:
- The best performance is often achieved by getting the performers out on stands.
- Although it has a broader range than most tower speakers, a subwoofer is necessary for most bookshelf speakers.
If you are considering studio monitors vs bookshelf speakers, then we can help:
What Is the Difference Between Tower Vs Bookshelf Speakers?
Space Dimensions and Speaker Placement Flexibility
While floor space is a critical factor in choosing between bookshelf and tower speakers (also known as desktop and floorstanding speakers), it’s also important to consider where your speakers will be placed and how much room you have. It is equally important to consider the size of the room and how loudspeaker output will fill it.
The best bookshelf speakers will provide sufficient output for a small to medium-sized room. This is especially true if the majority of listening takes place in the vicinity or near the speakers. Floorstanding speakers work best in larger dedicated rooms, mainly if there are multiple seating areas.
Tower speaker systems can be challenging to install if you don’t have enough floor space, but bookshelf speakers will work well if you have shelves or furniture. They are designed to sit on top of the table so that they are easy to hear. There are some things you should keep in mind.
If bookshelf speakers are not available, they can be mounted on speaker stands if the furniture fits the setup.
Tower speaker systems are more space-friendly because they can be positioned vertically and don’t require a stand.
You should consider the extra space needed to place a subwoofer on your desktop and tower speakers to increase bass. Subwoofers are larger than loudspeakers and require more floor space.
Sound Quality and Acoustic Properties
Tower Speakers Vs Bookshelf have similar characteristics, which allow them to provide an immersive and convincing experience.
These include pinpoint accuracy in frequency response, the ability to stay true to the content, and the ability to present subtle details with a straightforward but convincing sonic statement when needed.
The bookshelf speakers vs tower should also have room-energizing output capabilities, excellent dynamic range, powerful mid-range, and effortless low-frequency extension (awesome basses). ).
The best-reviewed tower and bookshelf speakers have been praised for delivering the emotion and sensory experience that the director or musician intended.
They never get in the way of the music or movie and don’t add any sonic signature. Listening to the best-in-class loudspeaker system should make you lose track of time.
Here are some key considerations when it comes to the acoustic properties of desktop and Floorstanding speakers.
Volume and Sensitivity
Sometimes, bigger is better. This holds for volume capabilities.
In simple terms, a speaker’s volume refers to how loud a speaker can produce sounds good. Sensitivity refers to how easy it can do that.
Tower speaker systems are more prominent and can handle more amplification. They’re also much more sensitive the speaker. They can handle higher volumes without causing distortion like as handle bass sound.
You will have to sacrifice sound quality if you want to achieve the same volume using bookshelf speakers.
Tower speaker systems are for you if loud and clear are your priorities.
Dynamic and Bass Range
Low-frequency extension and output are the most important aspects of comparing tower speaker systems to desktop speakers for audiophiles and severe enthusiasts in hi-fi.
Many audiophiles stand firm to the sound quality and acoustic properties of bookshelf speakers. Other speakers will say tower speakers are better for full-range sound without the use of subwoofers. It all depends on your room, personal preferences, and the speakers’ output capabilities.
Let’s take a look back. One of the most critical factors in judging speaker performance, or their inability to handle the bass, is one of the most challenging things to do with a speaker.
Many loudspeakers (tall and tower) are not capable of playing below 40Hz. This means you miss out on music and movies that can create a mood and give you a sense of immersion you might not get otherwise. Subwoofers can be used with full-range tower speakers, which is why there are so many.
Tower speakers are more prominent than bookshelf or desktop speakers, which allows them to move more air through their drivers. This will enable them to produce deeper and more bass than standalone desktop speakers.
You can also find additional woofer drivers in tower speakers, which have even more bass. Towers are the best option if you want room-filling bass and don’t want subwoofers.
It would help if you kept in mind that many bookshelf speakers can be used without a subwoofer. Subwoofers can be a great option if you need the extra low-frequency muscle that only a dedicated subwoofer can offer.
For more information, visit our resource on setting the correct crossover frequency for your subwoofer to achieve the best performance.
Music or Movies?
It might surprise you to learn that different speakers can be used for other audio types.
Tower speakers are the best choice if you want to blast your favorite tunes and bring energy to your next house party. Tower speakers can handle all types of music, and they can deliver the sound at volume.
However, if you are more interested in movies, it is a good idea to invest in both Bookshelf Vs Tower Speakers.
You can use a bookshelf speaker in an L/R configuration to get surround sound with a receiver or center speaker in a minor system. They can be used as surround speakers, which is a significant advantage.
If you want to experience cinematic sound, you can buy bookshelf or tower speakers.
Budget
When deciding between tower and bookshelf speakers, budget is a crucial factor.
There are speakers for every price point, no matter if you want to spend $100 or $1000. Tower speakers, however, are more expensive and start at $500 for a decent model.
Bookshelf speakers of mid-range quality can be found for a lower price. If price is a significant concern, bookshelf speakers are a better option.
Center Channel Speakers
A bookshelf speaker is also known as a central channel speaker. This speaker is commonly used in home theater speaker systems.
A horizontal design is typical for a center channel speaker: standard bookshelf and floor-standing speakers house speakers with a vertical arrangement.
The tweeter is usually at the top and the midrange/woofer beneath the tweeter. Two midrange/woofers are often found on the right and left sides of a channel speaker, with a tweeter in its middle.
This horizontal design allows the speaker to be mounted on a wall or a shelf above or below a TV/video projection screen.
LCR Speakers: An LCR speaker is another type of speaker that can be used in home theater systems. LCR stands for Left, Center, and Right. An LCR speaker is a horizontal cabinet that houses speakers for left, center, and proper channels in a home theater system setup.
LCR speakers are often referred to as passive soundbars because of their horizontal design. LCR speakers are classified as passive soundbars because, unlike soundbars that produce sound, they require a connection to external amplifiers and a home theatre receiver to make a sound louder.
Its physical design, however, has some of its advantages, independent of how it is connected. There are no separate bookshelves for the left and right, and channel speakers. All functions are contained in a compact, space-saving cabinet.
The Paradigm Millenia 20 and the KEF FHT7003 are two examples of LCR speakers that can be freestanding.
The Dolby Atmos Factor: Dolby Atmos allows sound to be heard from above, and there are now additional speaker designs available for bookshelves and floor-standing speakers.
Ceiling-mounted speakers are the best way to achieve Dolby Atmos. Most people don’t want the hassle of drilling holes in their ceilings and running wire through their walls and ceilings. Two additional options allow sound to be directed vertically and reflect off a flat roof.
Vertically firing speaker module: These speaker modules have speaker drivers that point up at an angle. The speakers can be placed on the top of most of the current speaker layout’s front left/right, left/suitable surround bookshelves, or floor-standing speakers.
Bookshelf/floor-standing speakers with vertically firing drivers: These speakers include horizontal and vertical drivers within the same cabinet (no extra module is required). This reduces the number of speaker cabinets as are necessary for a setup.
Best Tower Vs Bookshelf Speakers
Edifier R1700bt
- Power output (RMS): 15W×2 (tweeter) +, 18W×2 (mid-bass driver)
- Input sensitivity: Line In1: 700±50mV; Line In2: 550±50mV
- Dimension: 154mm × 254mm × 214mm (W×H×D）
- Net weight: 6.6kg
- Frequency response: 60Hz-20kHz
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Lovely midrange
- Warm, smooth, enthusiastic sound
- Engaging and easy to listen to
- Smart finish and build
- Affordable price
Cons:
- Boomy bass sticks out a lot
- Slightly thin treble
- Controls need a better finish
R 625Fa Tower Speakers
- Size: 6.5″
- Weight 49.00lbs
- Technology Dolby Atmos
- Type Floorstanding
- Frequency Range 38 Hz – 21 kHz (+-3dB)
- Dimension 17.30×9.45×40.00
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Conforms to Dolby Atmos specifications
- Woofers with dual spun-copper heads
- Aluminum tweeter with linear travel suspension
- Tractrix Horn Technology
- Built-in elevation channel
- Woofers have magnetic shields
- Outstanding bass reflex
- Rear Tractrix port
- MDF cabinet
- Vinyl in luxurious wood grain design
Cons:
- A little heavy
- Packaging can be improved.
Bookshelf Vs Tower Speakers: Conclusion
How much sound you want to produce in a room is a significant factor when deciding between floor standing and bookshelf speakers. Floorstanding speakers will need a larger area to provide the same sound as a bookshelf speaker would in a smaller space.
A floor-standing speaker would be the best choice in a larger room or one that can accommodate a more prominent speaker. We hope that our tower speakers vs bookshelf home theater comparison can help you know more about what speakers are appropriate for your needs. Do you have any other questions that we did not cover here?
Video:
